An analysis of americas policy of containment by george kennan in 1947

In fact, it is not surprising that Kissinger would favor this kind of approach, since he was a historian of these diplomatic periods as an academic. For Lippmann, the program of economic assistance was not a part of containment; but to Kennan and others in the administration it was simply another tactic in the implementation of containment.

Those critics were actually very wrong— but they could not know about the then-secret American tactics. ByKennan was already counseling that Soviet-American diplomatic collaboration was impossible. Historian James Oakes explains the strategy: Kennan would not have cared much about Soviet exploits in this regard, but the US performed was rarely less active.

This section needs additional citations for verification. Its main concern is to make sure that it has filled every nook and cranny available to it in the basin of world power. This essentially ruled out any change in the unity of the Soviet bloc, in effect formalizing the Brezhnev doctrine.

Engagement with the Soviets on all matters of cultural, technical, and economic matters was just the sort of interaction for which Kennan had been striving. Kennan had not offered new thoughts or insights, but rather, at a critical juncture, had phrased in telling words the emerging analysis within the administration.

National Defense University Press, For example, NATO can only deter Russian threats to the territorial integrity, political stability, or financial security of member states in the Baltic and Black Sea regions if it defines clear red lines and how it will respond when those lines are crossed.

In most cases, he assumed, they would be sufficient. Even inhe did not adequately explain his years of public silence before correcting the record. The Truman administration seized the opportunity to declare the Cold War in the Truman Doctrine speech.

Soviet hostility to the West, in turn, was a result largely of the "neurotic world view" of Soviet leaders and of their need to create a foreign enemy to justify dictatorship at home.

Such an astronomical figure in military spending baffled Kennan, considering his emphasis on diplomacy. If this country is ever going to prosper again, we need to change things like cutting the excessive and unnecessary military spending and foreign aid. McCarthy was a senator who frequently went to the senate drunk.

What is our policy toward Latin America? The result was a virtual stalemate in this area. For the most part, America remained "cool and collected", as Kennan preferred. It was a way of life.

Averell HarrimanU. Kennedy announced that they would put a man on the moon within ten years; they did it in eight years. History was on the side of the West. Many of the questions about containment, if it is interpreted as the general course of American foreign policy, become the basic questions about that policy itself, from Harry S.

They offended his taste, his sensibility, and his values. More importantly, NSC recognized that force was all that could be used in containing the Soviets because that was all that they would understand.

Applying this logic in the s, others could argue that the Truman Doctrine and the counsel of "X" shaped, if not dictated, the commitment of U. He proposed, in the words of an associate, tactics "designed to convince the Russians of our serious intent and of the consequences if they chose to continue their present course.

George Kennan Is Still the Russia Expert America Needs

For, presumably, Kennan did not think that the United States should rely in every case on words of support, friendly advice, and economic assistance, even if they were inadequate. While agreeing on the desirability of resisting communist expansion, Kennan and others disagreed on whether the doctrine remained relevant, and how and where to implement it.

Geogre Kennon message is true or false i donot no. Mayers Voice of America and Radio Free Europe were two early applications of this, and Carter and Reagan both emphasized human rights throughout the Soviet bloc in order to stir up their citizenry. Even more troubling is that neither side has offered much of a framework for managing — let alone resolving — the new geopolitical standoff.

As well, Kennan wanted the USA to show it "has a spiritual vitality capable of holding its own among the major ideological currents of the time. How long—Vyacheslav Molotov, the Soviet foreign minister, had asked earlier—could, say, Romania or Bulgaria remain independent of the West after the introduction of American capital?The basis of the doctrine was articulated in a cable by U.S.

diplomat George F. Kennan during the post-World War II administration of U.S. President Harry S In JanuaryKennan drafted an essay entitled "The Sources of Soviet Conduct Truman approved a classified statement of containment policy called NSC 20/4 in November Feb 22,  · George Kennan and the Long Telegram.

In my analysis, our policy toward China seems reactive rather than proactive because of the financial box of using China as an ATM to fund deficit spending. Our policy toward the major powers of Europe at times borders on arrogance. It looks as if George Kennan's legendary "containment" of.


Containment, associated with the American diplomat George F. Kennan, was the central post-war concept of the US and its allies in dealing with the Soviet Union. Containment kept the cold war from. An Analysis of George Kennan's Article "America's Policy of Containment" PAGES 2.

WORDS 1, View Full Essay. More essays like this: america s policy of containment, geroge kennan, article. Not sure what I'd do without @Kibin - Alfredo Alvarez, student @ Miami University.

George Kennan believed that the Soviet Union was a rational state so containment was a viable option; “when the Berlin Blockade (), Cuban missile crisis () and invasion of Afghanistan () failed, it withdrew its forces.

- Containment and the Cold War In FebruaryGeorge F. Kennan, an American diplomat in Moscow, proposed a policy of containment. Containment is the blocking .

An analysis of americas policy of containment by george kennan in 1947
Rated 4/5 based on 1 review